Your withdrawal decisions can have a crucial impact on your portfolio's long-term prospects, so there are a number of factors you'll want to consider. In addition to maintaining your overall asset allocation and appropriate levels of diversification, you'll also want to establish a withdrawal rate that will sustain your savings over the long haul. And of course, you'll want to try to reduce taxes.

Fidelity has developed a set of five guidelines to help you create and maintain a withdrawal plan that is tax-efficient, based on federal income taxes. Bear in mind that these are only general guidelines, since there is no single order appropriate for all investors. In some cases, transfer tax planning or other tax issues and planning considerations may lead you to formulate different withdrawal strategies. Your ultimate decisions should reflect your personal circumstances and take into account any tax and non-tax tradeoffs that may be necessary, so you should consult with a tax adviser to formulate a withdrawal strategy that is best for you.

Note that it is always important to maintain your investment strategy. Rebalancing is a potential issue regardless of from where you take withdrawals, but it's especially important when you target withdrawals from a particular asset class. If your planned withdrawals will skew your asset allocation, try to ensure that you can rebalance your portfolio without generating significant capital gains. You may be able to avoid current taxes when rebalancing by exchanging securities within your tax-advantaged accounts.

Top

Action Steps

For a detailed discussion about the withdrawal hierarchy in a printable format, see Orderly Approach. (PDF)

  1. Take your minimum required distributions (MRDs ).

    If you are age 70½ or older, make sure you know which of your accounts require such distributions and how large those distributions need to be, then meet the deadlines to avoid penalties.

      Learn about Taking Withdrawals After Age 70½.

  2. Liquidate loss positions in taxable accounts.

    Some investments in your taxable accounts may be worth less than their tax basis (generally the amount you paid to acquire them). In addition to offsetting (netting) realized losses against realized gains, at the federal level you can usually use up to $3,000 ($1,500 for married couples filing separately) of net losses each year to offset ordinary income such as interest, salaries, and wages. Unused losses can usually be carried forward for use in future years.

  3. Sell assets in taxable accounts that will generate neither capital gains nor capital losses.

    Such assets might include money market funds or other cash-equivalent investments. If your withdrawals largely come from cash-equivalent investments, be sure to leave sufficient liquid assets investments intact to cover any short-term financial emergencies and be especially mindful of potential rebalancing issues (as discussed above).

  4. Withdraw money from taxable accounts or tax-deferred saving vehicles funded with at least some nondeductible (or after-tax) contributions, such as variable annuities and Traditional IRAs.

    Fidelity's research has found that the choice depends on the circumstances, and in some cases, it might make more sense to tap the tax-deferred vehicle first. Assuming there is a significant difference in the basis-to-value ratio of the assets to be liquidated in two accounts (in other words, the tax basis of the assets divided by their current value), the best tactic for choosing between these two types of withdrawals is often to liquidate the assets with the higher ratio. That is, the assets that have generated the smallest gain or the largest loss as a percentage of their basis. If the basis-to-value ratio of the assets to be liquidated in each account is relatively low as a percentage of their basis, such as in the case of significant investment gains, it often will be preferable to liquidate the assets in the taxable account. Conversely, if the basis-to-value ratio of the assets to be liquidated in each account is relatively high, it may be preferable to liquidate assets in the tax-deferred account. Note that tax-deferred accounts are generally subject to certain aggregation requirements when allocating basis. Consult with your tax adviser for additional details.

    When liquidating gain positions in taxable accounts, it usually makes sense to sell assets with long-term capital gains first, since they should be taxed at lower rates than short-term gains are. In addition, consider liquidating assets that are likely to generate smaller taxable gains when expressed in dollar terms.

    If you are thinking of leaving assets to beneficiaries, this fourth guideline may not serve you well. See About Estate Planning for more information.

  5. Withdraw money from tax-deferred accounts funded with deductible (or pre-tax) contributions such as 401(k)s and Traditional IRAs or tax-exempt accounts such as Roth IRAs.

    Fidelity's research suggests that, contrary to popular wisdom, it may not make much difference which account you tap first within this category assuming (1) all withdrawals from any tax-deferred accounts funded with fully deductible (or pre-tax) contributions are taxed at the same rate throughout your retirement and (2) when you withdraw money from the tax-deferred account funded with fully deductible (or pre-tax) contributions, you'll have to take out enough to cover taxes. As a result, you'll have less money continuing to grow on your behalf than if you had taken a qualified tax-exempt distribution of a smaller sum from a tax-exempt account.

    If you believe that withdrawals you make may be subject to different tax rates over the course of your retirement (for example, based on changes to tax laws or to your levels of income) you may be better off liquidating one type of account within this fifth guideline before another. For example, it may make more sense to leave your Roth account intact if you thought your ordinary income tax rate was likely to rise in later years, increasing the value of the Roth's tax exemption. Estate planning considerations may also significantly impact this guideline.

Top

About Estate Planning

If your primary concern is leaving assets to beneficiaries, then with respect to the fourth guideline above, you may want to avoid selling assets in taxable accounts that have risen significantly in value. Under current federal tax law, beneficiaries of securities held in taxable accounts will usually receive a stepped-up cost basis (the adjusted purchase price of an asset assumed for calculating gains or losses) that usually equals the assets' market value when you die. That means they shouldn't have to pay taxes on gains that accrued during your lifetime, so selling such assets now might expose you, your estate, and/or your heirs to unnecessary tax liabilities.

With respect to the fifth guideline, you may want to consider withdrawing from tax-deferred accounts funded with fully deductible (or pretax) contributions before tax-exempt accounts. After income taxes are taken into account, the same net withdrawal amount may result in a larger withdrawal from the pretax account than from the tax-exempt account, thus potentially reducing estate taxes (which are based on total assets). In addition, unlike tax-deferred monies, your beneficiaries should not have to pay income taxes on withdrawals from most tax-exempt accounts provided certain requirements are met. You should consult a tax advisor and/or an estate planning professional regarding taxes and other issues related to estate planning.

    Top

    Final Considerations

    Fidelity's retirement withdrawal guidelines won't always lead to the perfect withdrawal sequence for your retirement assets. But the important thing is to be aware of the issues that arise when you make withdrawals. Maximizing the after-tax proceeds from all of your accounts does not necessarily mean trying to achieve the smallest immediate tax bill. Be careful to avoid withdrawal decisions that are based only on short-term considerations. Keep your long-term asset allocation in mind. You should consider consulting with a tax adviser to formulate your own withdrawal strategy.

      Top

      Tax information contained herein is general  in nature, is provided for informational purposes only, and should not be construed as legal or tax advice. Fidelity does not provide legal or tax advice. Fidelity cannot guarantee that such information is accurate, complete, or timely. Laws of a particular state or laws which may be applicable to a particular situation may have an impact on the applicability, accuracy, or completeness of such information. Federal and state laws and regulations are complex and are subject to change. Changes in such laws and regulations may have a material impact on pre- and/or after-tax investment results. Fidelity makes no warranties with regard to such information or results obtained by its use. Fidelity disclaims any liability arising out of your use of, or any tax position taken in reliance on, such information. Always consult an attorney or tax professional regarding your specific legal or tax situation.

      PDFs require Adobe® Reader®.

      Fidelity Investments Home
      Copyright 1998–2009 FMR LLC
      All rights reserved.
      Terms of Use Privacy Security Site Map